Jeremy Rosado sang his version of “Ribbon in the Sky” on American Idol Season 11 Top 13 Wednesday night.

According to the judges, Steven: “Beautiful voice. Velvety high—great song, nice passion.” Jennifer: “I love to hear your interpretation of songs. That was really really beautiful.” Randy: “For me, it wasn’t your best song. This is a difficult song. It’s the kind of song that you have to put more swag in it in order to really make it believable.”

Watch his performance below.